10-12 Lyman Street, Port Jervis, NY, 12771

Charming Duplex with a Barn Garage on a Double Lot! A rare and versatile investment opportunity awaits at 10 & 12 Lyman St—a beautifully maintained Victorian duplex paired with a barn-style garage on a separate lot, all set on .23 acres in the heart of Port Jervis! Whether you're looking for owner-occupancy with rental income or a prime investment property, this unique setup offers endless possibilities. The Home – 10 Lyman St- This stunning 1800s Victorian was lovingly maintained by the same family for generations and now serves as a charming two-family home. Unit 1 (Main Level – 1,700+ sq. ft.) 3 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths (currently used as a 2-bedroom with office space) Spacious primary suite with an ensuite bath, Hardwood floors throughout and newer-style windows bringing in abundant natural light, Formal dining area with a built-in china cabinet nook, Large kitchen with granite countertops, two sinks, ample cabinetry, and a breakfast nook surrounded by built-ins and windows, French doors leading to a dedicated office (or third bedroom), Laundry in-unit, central A/C and forced-air heating, and plenty of closet space, Handicap-accessible entry via a ramp leading to the back porch overlooking the partially fenced yard Unit 2 (Second Floor – 780 sq. ft.) 2 Bedrooms, 1 Bath, Cozy living room and kitchen area with charming built-ins, Heat pump & ductless A/C for efficient heating and cooling The Barn Garage – 12 Lyman St -Sitting on its own lot with separate electric, this versatile structure offers: Two garage doors with side entry to a workshop, Expansive hayloft above—ideal for storage, a studio, or potential additional income, Long paved driveway for ample off-street parking, Prime Location & Investment Potential A true live-in, rent-out opportunity, or a fantastic full-investment property! Enjoy peaceful landscaping and paver walkways connecting both lots while being within walking distance to schools, shops, public transportation, and Port Jervis’ thriving downtown. With quick access to highways, NYC, and NJ transit, plus nearby hiking, biking, wineries, and the scenic Delaware River, this property offers both charm and convenience. New roof (2018) & numerous upgrades in recent years! Don’t miss out on this unique and historic property—schedule your private showing today!

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Hudson Valley 845-610-6065